What is the difference between flocculants PAC and PAM

Release time: 2025-07-23


⚗ I. Summary of essential differences

The dimension of comparison

PAC (polyaluminum chloride)

PAM (polyacrylamide)

 chemical property 

Inorganic polymer coagulant

Organic polymer flocculant

Appearance

Yellow/yellowish brown powder (the darker the color, the higher the iron content)

White powder or emulsion

Core mechanism

Electrical neutralization + coil net capture (to remove the instability of small particles)

Bridge adsorption + charge neutralization (long chain connected flocs)

Typical usage

200-300 mg/L (large dosage)

3-10 mg/L (extremely low dosage)

Residual risk

Residual aluminum ions (use with caution in drinking water)

Acrylamide monomer toxicity (food grade required)

 


 

�� II. Key features and application scenarios

PAC applicable scene 

  1. High turbidity wastewater: sand washing, printing and dyeing, papermaking wastewater
  2. Phosphorus removal enhancement: better effect when combined with iron salt
  3. Coagulant: rapidly destroy the stability of colloid and form initial flocs

PAM applicable scene 

  1. Sludge dewatering: Cationic type enhances sludge coagulation
  2. Fine sedimentation: anionic treatment of low turbidity wastewater
  3. Flocculation enlargement: small floccules generated by PAC are connected to form large flocculants

�� Combined advantages:

PAC (stabilizing colloid) is added first, and then PAM (amplifying flocculation) is added after 1-2 minutes, and the sedimentation efficiency is increased by more than 50%.

 


 

III. Key points and precautions

Dissolution configuration

  • PAC: Directly prepared into a 10-20% solution and dissolved by rapid stirring
  • PAM: it needs to be diluted into 0.1-0.3% solution, and the dissolution time is 40-50 minutes for slow addition to prevent agglomeration

Order of injection

Do not reverse the order: PAC first and PAM second, with an interval of at least 1 minute to ensure full reaction

 risk aversion 

  • PAM solution should be stored away from iron and light (iron ion catalytic degradation)
  • PAC (risk of aluminum residue) should be used with caution in drinking water treatment, and food grade PAM should be used instead

 


 

�� IV. Selection and economic suggestions

Demand scenario

Recommended medication

 account 

High turbidity wastewater/ phosphorus removal

PAC give first place to 

The unit price is low (thousand yuan/ton), but the amount is large

 sludge dewatering 

 cation PAM

Although the unit price is high (≥ 4000 yuan/ton), the amount is only 1/30 of PAC

Hard to settle wastewater

PAC+PAM combination

The cost was reduced by 30% and the density of flocs was increased by 2 times

 


 

❗ keynotes 

The actual dosage should be determined by small test in beaker, because excessive dosage will lead to re-dispersion of flocs.